[Info-Ingres] LEFT JOIN wrong results

"Wiśniewski, Piotr, (ProService AT)" Piotr.Wisniewski at psat.pl
Thu May 31 03:11:49 CDT 2007


There's an apparent bug in ingres version
patch seq  version                 
                                    
 12021   1  II 9.0.4 (a64.sol/105)  

concerning outer joins.
The first statement below returns wrong data.
The columns involved in the joins are decimal(9, 2).
Any comments are welcome.


  1> select  first 1                                
     p.id,                                          
     a.procent     ,                                
     a.fk_funduszid                                 
     from PRODUKT_UCZESTNIKA p                      
     LEFT JOIN OKRES o ON o.fk_produkt_uczeid=p.id  
     LEFT JOIN ALOKACJA a ON a.fk_okresid   =o.id   
     where        a.procent  is null                
                                                    
                                                
                                                    
                                                    
+----------+-------+-----------+                    
|id        |procent|fk_funduszi|                    
+----------+-------+-----------+                    
|         1|       |           |                    
+----------+-------+-----------+                    
 
  2> select                                         
     p.id,                                          
     a.procent     ,                                
     a.fk_funduszid                                 
     from PRODUKT_UCZESTNIKA p                      
     LEFT JOIN OKRES o ON o.fk_produkt_uczeid=p.id  
     LEFT JOIN ALOKACJA a ON a.fk_okresid   =o.id   
     where 1=1                                      
     and p.id=1                                     
                                                    
                                                    
                                                    
                                                    
+----------+-------+-----------+                    
|id        |procent|fk_funduszi|                    
+----------+-------+-----------+                    
|         1|  40,00|        163|                    
|         1|  30,00|        164|                    
|         1|  30,00|        161|                    
+----------+-------+-----------+                    
(3 rows)

                                                   
                                                   


More information about the Info-Ingres mailing list